let me first start by saying that this movie is wonderfully done. the score is beautiful and adds dramatically to the movie. the scenes are perfectly placed and the plain colored backgrounds with new time frames are the most perfect, forgetful colors. the most perfect colors to match the theme of the movie but so well integrated within the theme of the movie that they are hard to remember particularly.
the question “is the situation in never let me go ethical?” was raised in class today and i want to discuss that. it won’t take much since i have the strongest arguments on my side: ethics and morals. no, it isn’t ethical to raise HUMAN BEINGS WITH FULLY COMPREHENSIVE EMOTIONS AND CONSCIOUSNESS to be donors. their entire life purpose is to donate their entire body to other people. while that is a solution, in no world is that the right one. they know their fate is certain. they know what their purpose is. but that does not make it okay. they are human beings. you cannot raise a “crop” of people for a specific purpose. we raise animals for the purpose of food. not house pets but livestock. now while some people may debate that that these two situations are similar, they are not. we (society not ME) view animals as a class below us. we evolved past them, we are greater. the food chain dictates that we are above animals, despite us breaking the animal-human boundary and other opinions. we raise them for food. HUMANS on the other hand are our equals. yes, they are clones but are they emotionless purely physical clones? no, they are fully comprehensive clones. they feel, they want, they have souls. it is unethical, wrong, and disturbing.